SFX
SFX Merchandise
Newsletter

20090120 Tuesday January 20, 2009

Tonight's Battlestar Galactica and the final Cylon [SPOILERS]

Well, that was pretty intense! US fans saw it last Friday, but the hotly anticipated return of Battlestar Galactica hit UK screens this evening, and just in case you clicked onto this page by mistake, we've hidden our comments on episode 4.13 ("Sometimes A Great Notion") below - highlight the text to read it.

HIGHLIGHT HERE IF YOU WANT TO KNOW:


"FRAK EARTH!" reads the graffiti in one of the Galactica's corridors. This is the exciting return that we were waiting for; sci-fi doesn't get much more thrilling - or morose - than this. The title of the episode is almost certainly taken from an old folk song called “Goodnight, Irene”: "Sometimes I get a great notion/To jump in the river and drown" and you can see how this applies to the theme of the episode.

The Cylons and humans working together have found the Earth, but it was nuked about 2000 years ago. And the remains they find seem to confirm that the lost 13th tribe were Cylons, not humans. Yikes. The gritty, washed out opening scenes couldn't really have been bleaker and you can tell from just five minutes in, as Dualla weeps over a child's plaything, that it's not going to have a cheerful resolution. We're wrongfooted because she seems to have reconciled herself to the situation and is even giggling with Lee after a drink at the bar. So when it comes, Dualla's suicide is sudden, effortless and heartbreaking.

And what do discoveries on the surface mean for Starbuck? If she's not the final Cylon (and the revelation that it was Ellen Tigh all along is unexpected but dramatically played in the final moments) then how do we explain her dead body in the crashed Viper?

The pacing is noteworthy. There's a great deal of silence, and hardly any dialogue at first - even Roslin's returning address to the fleet is just her shaking her head. The only mis-step is Bill Adama's over-long drunken session with Saul Tigh, which seems to drag although it is excellently acted. The episode delivers a few answers, tugs on plot threads we've been following for years, and asks enough new questions to mean we can't wait for the rest of the season. It has a mythic sense about it, branching out from the usual on-ship claustrophobia to place our favourite characters in the context of a wider, ancient, confusing universe - there's a sense of madness about it too (insanity borne of disappointment, no doubt).

And so the journey beings again, to find a new home that isn't Earth! One thing's for sure - this is not a TV show to watch if you've had a bad day...

So, what did you think of the show? Is the final Cylon somebody you'd guessed? We bet it wasn't (unless you caved and read all the spoilers from the US on the net already).

Share your thoughts below in the comments thread, or head to the forum. Where do you think the season's going to go now? We linked to some of the speculations about what this all means, back here. You can read our "official" Spoiler Zone reviews of Battlestar Galactica, complete with star ratings, in the pages of SFX magazine.


Advertisement
Trackback URL:
Comments:

Again, BSG delivers an episodes full of insight to what it is to be human, and how we deal with certain situations, as well as providing a few WTF moments along the way. I've always wondered why the fifth cylon didn't hear the music and I have been speculating about who wasn't on the Galactica at the time the rest heard it! Now it all makes sense, and its even more poignant as Tigh killed her!

Bravo people fopr delivering a great opening episode xxx

Posted by Jacqui (127.0.0.1) on January 20, 2009 at 10:33 PM GMT #

Episode 4.11 not 4.13, shurely ?

Posted by me (127.0.0.1) on January 20, 2009 at 10:46 PM GMT #

Nope, they're calling it 4.13. Because technically the Razor story is considered parts 1 and 2 of season four, so the "first" ten episodes were really numbered 3-12. Confusing isn't it?! Check out the link for the list of Battlestar episodes on Wikipedia. May contain spoilers.

Posted by Dave Bradley (127.0.0.1) on January 20, 2009 at 11:56 PM GMT
Website: http://tinyurl.com/yexe7c #

I thought this made an excellent season opener and the surprises it chucked our way were just that BIG surprises that catch you off guard! Welcome back battlestar although how long until Sky 1 has one of those "Have you been affected by tonights episode" helplines?

Posted by Matt (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 08:46 AM GMT #

A complex, glowering episode that leaves most other television drama (sf or otherwise) in BSG's capacious shadow.

It was unsettling and bleakly funny in places. Dee's suicide was shocking but treated in a refreshingly unsentimental way that reminded me of Patrice Leconte's The Hairdresser's Husband. The revelation about the Cylon '13th Tribe' reinforced something that has been emphasized at various points in BSG: these people don't understand their own history, or even their own nature. I suspect that the Cylon/Human distinction is going to become increasingly blurry and moot.

Posted by David Roden (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 08:48 AM GMT
Website: http://www.enemyindustry.net #

@Matt I think there is going to need to be some kind of post traumatic stress hotline put in place if they keep up with this level of bleakness through the entire season. It's amazing, intelligent, thought provoking and moving television with stellar performances all round (Michael Hogan especially), but I just don't know if it can be called entertaining anymore. SO bleak!

And as for the death of Dee... I was watching it with a friend and as she kissed Apollo goodbye and went into her quarters I said 'oh, thank goodness, there HAS to be something nice happening this episode to level out the depressing stuff because otherwise it's just --'. Bang. Ron Moore is a genius. But he is a twisted twisted genius.

I can't help thinking the final cylon is a red herring - as otherwise what is Starbuck? She has to be a kind of cylon too surely? Otherwise how do you explain the wreckage?

It's so great watching shows that have such depth they make your head hurt. I really can't wait for the rest of this.

Posted by narin (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 09:32 AM GMT #

Brilliant... depressing.... but brilliant... M

Posted by Marc Atkinson (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 09:49 AM GMT
Website: http://www.marcatkinson.co.uk #

I bet they reveal a different possible final Cylon each week - I thought they wern't going to reveal who th final Cylon is until episode nine??!?

Posted by Voyager Hater (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 10:01 AM GMT #

i agree with almost all of the above review and comments.

However as narin and Voyager Hater have suggested...the fact that we are presented with two POSSIBLE answers to the final Cylon riddle suggests mind games played not only with the audience, but with the characters...surely we only have Saul's conclusion from a single remembered comment to go on, whereas the corpse on "cursed (read nuked) Earth" is more suggestive?

As for the drunken confrontation between Bill and Saul, I loved the reversal of roles there. The alcoholic telling his friend that he's had too much and thus, for once, becoming the voice of reason...too long? Frack that!

All told brilliant...as only BSG can be.

Posted by james (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 10:57 AM GMT #

Absolutely loved it from start to finish. I don't think that the revelation regarding the final cylon is a red herring as it makes much more sense for it to be Ellen than pretty much anyone else on the show. From the moment she was introduced there was speculation about her and her actions proved to be dangerous and detrimental to the humans' fight for survival on many occasions.

There's only one problem now. If BG manages to maintain this level of quality to the end of its run (and all indications are that it will) how can any other TV SF show ever compare? Rewatching Enterprise on Virgin at the moment just seems to emphasise how basic and unsophisticated Star Trek and other similar shows are compared to BSG. Don't get me wrong - I'm a big ST fan - but it just seems to me that BG represents the pinacle of SF TV. At least we have Caprica to look forward to...

Posted by Mr T (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 12:40 PM GMT #

Did anybody else see that the dogtags found in the crashed viper had a silver ring on them. Also Dee places her silver ring on her dogtags in her locker door. I know that they seem to have revealed the final cylon, but I can't shake the idea we're being duped. The camera focused too long on both rings for me to ignore it.

Call me crazy, but I think Dee is actually the final cylon and Saul was a bit drunk and lonely.

Posted by Asylum (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 12:48 PM GMT #

I believe Ronald D. Moore and Kate Vernon have confirmed that Ellen is 100% the Final Cylon.

It's a fascinating choice. On her introduction, Head-Six immediately sensed something was up with her: "We have something interesting here, don't we?" And when she 'died' her last words were "You've ALWAYS been there for me." Whilst the producers confirm they only fixed on Ellen as the choice for the Fifth during the writing of Season 3, apparently they'd been swirling the notion around since her introduction, so unlike Tigh, Anders and Tory (Tyrol had been chosen in the S2 finale, hence his weird dreams, connection to Cavill and later finding the temple on the algae planet) there was a bit more foreshadowing for her than the others.

Of course, this episode tells us that the 13th Tribe Cylons can be detected using information on the 'current' humanoid Cylons. Which leads to the question...what did Baltar's test really show at the end of Ellen's introductory episode ("I'll never tell," he said at the time)?

Posted by Adam Whitehead (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 02:07 PM GMT
Website: http://thewertzone.blogspot.com/ #

Unreal, unbeliveable and quite,quite brillaint. One of the best episodes of any tv show i've seen. the way it seemlessly flowed from the one crisis to next, and Dee, masterly, could believe it.
I have come up with a new theory. i think the cylons on earth were what humans developed into through cybornetics etc., but wiped them selves out in a war, left earth for kobal where they bred a new civilisation of humans would in turn went to the colonies and developed the cylons, cycles, all lee obin talked about at first was cycles.
I amy be crazy, but i said to friends that i thought saul was one of the final five and they scoffed!
BSG is the defining sci fi of our time and will be remebered as such

Posted by David (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 05:15 PM GMT #

Cool episode. Can't wait for next weeks. Slightly amazed that the usual suspects who pop up on here to tell us that BSG is rubbish haven't bothered to do so.

Perhaps they've been distracted by some pretty lights or something.

Posted by Bob (127.0.0.1) on January 21, 2009 at 06:16 PM GMT #

Rather than fear that Sci-Fi TV can only go downhill from here on out, I would like to think that we have been at the very beginning of a revolution. Solidarity Brothers and Sisters.

(Oh and I can't help myself any longer...this quality of TV is what Doctor Who should be....one can only dream.)

Posted by James (127.0.0.1) on January 22, 2009 at 02:42 PM GMT #

Well, Doctor Who and Battlestar Galactica are very different programmes for different time-slots and aimed at different audiences, so I wouldn't expect the writing in Doctor Who to be like the writing in BSG. That said, I think they're both excellent programmes of their type.

Posted by Bob (127.0.0.1) on January 22, 2009 at 03:02 PM GMT #

Battlestar Galactica is Sci-Fi Shakespeare.

Everything else is pulp fantasy fiction

Posted by James (127.0.0.1) on January 26, 2009 at 12:57 AM GMT #

In contrast to virtually all the comments above, I think this was the episode where I realised one important thing: I no longer care what happens in Battlestar Galactica. Yes, there are some fantastic moments, but Dualla's suicide was one of those scenes that initially seems daring and shocking, until you realise it's also an absolutely shameless bit of emotional manipulation that's designed specifically to make you first go "Awwww...." and then go "OMG!!!". It's the kind of episode that I kinda liked directly after I first watched it, but has plummeted in my opinion since, and as for the Ellen Tigh revelation - who cares? Does that revelation actually make any difference whatsoever? (For a moment, I actually thought Dualla was going to turn out to be the Fifth, a revelation that might actually have been more interesting than hitting the 'Let's kill off another minor female character' button. Most of the 'big moments' are now playing more like someone randomly throwing darts at a blackboard, and I also don't think the writing is particularly good- yes, there's moments where it's fantastic, but its also developed (over the last couple of years) a sense of over-serious portentiousness that annoys the hell out of me. Having also watched 4.14 (ep 2 of this bunch), the whole show is just going in an evermore bleak direction, I'm finding it difficult to care about a good 80% of the cast, and I'm fed up of the show hitting me over the head with how IMPORTANT and RESONANT and MYTHIC it all is. For all its ups and downs, I loved the show up until the end of S2, and really until about 7 episodes in S3. Things have been very, very shaky since then, and while major amounts of love are being thrown in BSG's direction, I think a little bit of distance is called for. Important, serious and bleak doesn't always equal good, and while BSG is undoubtedly an impressive show overall, it's a long long way from being as unconditionally wonderful as everybody's saying it is...

Posted by Saxon Bullock (127.0.0.1) on January 29, 2009 at 05:32 PM GMT
Website: http://www.saxonbullock.com #

Oh and I can't help myself any longer...this quality of TV is what Doctor Who should be....one can only dream.)

What a pile of Rubbish, Dr who is vastly superior to BSG any day of the week. Dr who's future is secure while BSG has been axed due to low ratings, Dr who is massively popular not only her but all over Europe, BSG isn't, Dr who has a successful 40 odd yeat history, BSG has a failed 1980's series, a failed spin off series and a failed revamp. The facts speak for themselves, DR who IS BETTER than BSG and the small amount of whiners won't and can't change that so deal with it and move on. I'm just glad it's finally been put out of it's misery.

Posted by BSGHATER (127.0.0.1) on February 12, 2009 at 08:21 AM GMT #

Post a Comment:

Name:
E-Mail:
URL:

Your Comment:

HTML Syntax: NOT allowed
SFX Movie Trailers

Calendar