SFX
SFX Merchandise
Newsletter

20080730 Wednesday July 30, 2008

FILM REVIEW: Star Wars: The Clone Wars


15 August

Director: Dave Filoni

Starring (voices): Matt Lanter, Ashley Eckstein, James Arnold Taylor, Anthony Daniels, Christopher Lee, Samuel L Jackson

Rating:

The 20th Century Fox fanfare is such an integral part of the Star Wars experience that seeing the Warner Brothers shield dissolving into “A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away...” is a rather disconcerting experience. The absence of an opening crawl – to say what it’s been replaced with would be an unfair spoiler – and slightly remixed theme tune do nothing but add to the suspicion that The Clone Wars comes from a very different place to the live-action movies.

But make no mistake, as soon as you’re plunged into the heart of a Jedi vs battledroids confrontation on a distant world, this is pure, unadulterated Star Wars. The characters may be heavily stylised CG caricatures of the saga’s heroes and villains, but the essence of George Lucas’s creation remains in a movie that bests at least two of the prequels. Indeed, The Clone Wars’ brand of simplistic, action-heavy storytelling is a fantastic breath of fresh air after the complex political machinations that bogged down much of Episodes I and II.

The film’s biggest strength is that it’s clearly been made by fans for fans. It’s easy to picture planning meetings dissolving into sessions of “Wouldn’t it be cool if...” particularly when Anakin leads a vertical assault on a distant temple, clone troopers and giant walkers scaling a massive cliff as Separatist fire rains down on them. The movie is packed with sequences that more than hold their own against their live-action equivalents.

And while it’s hardly Apocalypse Now, Clone Wars doesn’t sanitise the violence. Some scenes are surprisingly brutal: a battledroid grabbing a trooper by the neck before shooting him point blank is up there with the charred corpses of Luke’s aunt and uncle in the Star Wars pantheon of unpleasantness. This is the Clone Wars as many fans of the original trilogy wanted to see them, much closer to the prequels that existed in our heads than The Phantom Menace turned out to be.

As a curtain-raiser to the upcoming Clone Wars TV series – set to continue filling the gaps between Episodes II and III – this is an impressive statement of intent. The CG proves surprisingly effective, with the cast’s cartoony, almost puppet-like appearance perfectly suiting the material. The animation may not possess Pixar levels of complexity – probably impossible when you’ve eventually got to churn out weekly episodes – but with its vibrant colour scheme and simple, get-to-the-point dialogue, The Clone Wars is straight out of the comic-book school of storytelling. Needless to say, the hardware and spaceships look fantastic – you have to look very hard to see where what you see here differs from the (admittedly just as CG) equivalents in the prequels.

Although the mention of protecting shipping lanes through the Outer Rim conjures unpleasant memories of Trade Federation blockades, the plot involving the kidnap of Jabba the Hutt’s son rarely lets the excitement levels dip – in fact, the action’s so relentless that come the final quarter you might find yourself begging for a breather. Slug Jr proves an ingenious McGuffin, both a convincing reason for conflict between the Republic and Count Dooku’s Separatists (both sides want to keep Jabba onside) and a brilliant plot device for exploring the relationship between future Vader Anakin Skywalker and his new Padawan learner, Ahsoka Tano, when they have to play nursemaid.

That the character stuff works as well as it does is a welcome surprise. Cartoon Anakin proves to be a much more likeable character than the Hayden Christensen version, suggesting he might become the rogue-ish Han Solo character the prequels lacked, while one glance between Anakin and secret missus Padme, shared via hologram, conveys more sexual chemistry than any number of musings about the romantic properties of sand.

The newbies, too, fare well, with the impetuous Ahsoka mostly avoiding the annoying qualities that are usually the hallmark of a screen sidekick, and Asajj Ventress displaying plenty of menace and her fair share of skill with a lightsaber. Even the usually faceless clones are given a chance to develop, with their different haircuts (some of them hilarious) suggesting they’ve grown individual personalities. Above all The Clone Wars is fun. Sure, a few gags fall flat, but this gets back to the adventure serial roots that first inspired George Lucas all those years ago. The kid in you will love it.

Richard Edwards

Advertisement
Trackback URL:
Comments:

I actually really want to see this, this review makes it sound good I hope so, my poor heart couldn't take more bad Star Wars

Posted by Ben Hazuki (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 02:10 AM BST #

Sounds like this in its own way will be as entertaining as A NEW HOPE. Great! Can't wait to see it on Big Screen, and one to see up there more than once! (If only all STAR WARS could be like this!) Well done everybody concerned! :)

Posted by Sean Gibbons (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 02:50 AM BST #

Geez louise, can we get through anything anymore without the bizarre need to bash any of the prequel trilogy?

I'm 39 years old, I first saw ANH in 1977, and dammit, I love the prequels too. I love all of the Star Wars movies without apology. Kiss my old fan butt you herd-following droolers.

Posted by Me (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 04:42 AM BST #

I knew i wanted to see this after watching the trailers but now it has to be seen after reading that review, fingers crossed for great things!!

Posted by Matt (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 08:17 AM BST #

Sick of all the prequels knocking, they were brilliant, simple as. Yes you actually had to THINK with TPM and AOTC which actually isn't a crime, the fact they broke records in terms of money made from cinema and DVD sales says just how good these films were. I've lost count how many times i've watch all 6 films and loved them even more than the last time. These films are classics and will still be remembered in 30 years time.

I have no doubt that this has been made with as much love and brilliance that all 6 Star Wars were made with. Looks very good and i'm sure will do well in the cinema.

Bad Star Wars film????? Sorry no such thing!!!

Posted by Cybos (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 08:25 AM BST #

Re:Cybos
Bad Star Wars film????? Sorry no such thing!!!
Posted by Cybos (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 08:25 AM BST


Err...Have you seen 'Caravan of Courage' and 'The Battle for Endor'???? BAD Star Wars Films!!!!

The Prequels? Well they were fun I guess..ROTS being the best...

Posted by Pete (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 08:58 AM BST #

"herd-following droolers"

Surely that should be NERF herd following droolers?

Posted by slink (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 09:02 AM BST #

No such thing as a Bad star wars Movie..clearly you are easily pleased..Revenge of the sith was in my opinion the only good prequel for its balance of humour, adventure and darkness but it still was a CGI fest with the only real acting left to Palpatine..Phantom menace and Attack of the clones did make me think..I thought didn't George lucas used to write inventive, funny, exciting movies? like star wars, indiana jones, american graffitti, the prequel trilogy was clearly a vanity project that gave the fans a thrill til they actually sat in the cinema and witnessed Bland writing, cliche characters and an over reliance on CGI. How much money a film made does not make it a film of quality, the prequel will be remembered for the quick cash in and hype machine they were. Sorry but Enjoy them if you must, but deep down you must know that the prequel trilogy and the new spin offs are fast food chicken nuggets to the origional films steak and chips.

Posted by Reply To Cybos (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 09:10 AM BST #

Err...Have you seen 'Caravan of Courage' and 'The Battle for Endor'???? BAD Star Wars Films!!!!

These two films were not Star Wars Films, they were Ewok films, nothing to do with the Star Wars legacy or History.

And reply to Cybos, nothing to do with being easily pleased, more to do with enjoying these films as much as sitting down in 1977, 1980 and 1983 and enjoying episodes 4 - 6. I got the same level of excitement and enjoyment that i got all those years ago. You didn't fair enough but millions did and your distinct lack of taste has no relevance to the success of these films. these films are mega successes and the whinging of a few muppets doesn't alter that in the slightest.

Steak and chips, yes they are but now instead of 4 portions, i get 6 and damn fine they are too.

Posted by Cybos (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 10:20 AM BST #

Star Wars!!!wooooooooooooo!!!

Posted by Jedi Dan (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 02:48 PM BST #

You are not a sad chap, it's cool to exchange points of view

...6 portions of steak & chips? more like 3 portions of steak & chips, a rich full bodied red and a sulculent cheese cake and 3 re-heated last nights chinease in the microwave with a flat belgium beer and a mini milk. Millions of People went to see the 'new' star wars..millions left non-plused, I've met people who didn't bother with Ep 3 as the other 2 were so lame

I have yet to meet someone who regards the 1-3 films and anywhere near as cool as 4-6, it's not a nostalgia thing if it was we would all be praising Howard The Duck for its 80's retro-ness. I'd rather be a Muppet than a total Jar Jar!

Posted by reply to a reply to Cybos (127.0.0.1) on July 31, 2008 at 03:52 PM BST #

Reply To Cybos:

yo dude, palpatine was awful in star wars III. totally over the top and almost campy.

Posted by brian (127.0.0.1) on August 01, 2008 at 12:41 AM BST #

i'm with cybos. i also saw the original 3 when i was just a kid and became a fan. actually, at the risk of an onslaught of ridicule, i really like the prequels even more. i have watched all 6 time and again, but my fav's are the prequels.

Posted by kim (127.0.0.1) on August 02, 2008 at 12:40 AM BST #

to be fair to all involved, if you look at objectively, or from the non-really big starwars-fan viewpoint, the prequels did not get close to the originals. i liked starwars, not a lot, but they were fine,and at least they had some heart to them and that you can only admire.the prequels felt empty, at least to me, especially with what they could have been. i hope, for star wars fans sake, this animated movies is good, for yer not a bad bunch. however, for most of us main stream sci fi fans, the prequels just didn't do it!

Posted by daithimor@gmail.com (127.0.0.1) on August 02, 2008 at 05:35 PM BST #

Hey, to me I thought all the star wars were great. Truely, it was Lucas' original dream to have great special effects and use them for star wars, so if he would have had them for episodes 4-6 they would have looked the same as 1-3. Also, If you realy look into the emotions of the characters in 1-3, you will see that they really had much heart in them. I mean its an awsome thing to see the great jedi knight anakin skywalker a brave heroic leader transform into a ruthless evil sith. Honestly if you are a die hard star wars fan you will still feel the excitement and fun in the prequels as you do in the sequels.

Posted by Isaiah (127.0.0.1) on August 02, 2008 at 11:39 PM BST #

And once again, I'm having to remove comments for mudslinging.

Impersonating other users in order to fling insults at them is pathetic and childish. And flinging insults back only brings you down to their level.

Apologies to those who included legitimate comments on the film or Star Wars in general, but whose comments were removed due to the aforementioned mudslinging. Feel free to repost your reviews, but let's stay away from childish to-ing and fro-ing, yes?

Posted by Leah (127.0.0.1) on August 05, 2008 at 10:19 AM BST
Website: http://www.sfx.co.uk #

Poor Leah. You must feel like a kindergarten teacher sometimes.

Posted by 127.0.0.1 on August 05, 2008 at 04:40 PM BST #

get a grip star wars is for kids and the kids inside us when ben speaks about the clone wars in new hope we all created a picture.but then you blame lucas for not creating that picture. i love all star wars. after the prequals in the cinemas people were coming out exited and happy in all three it was only later this started .so a lot of diologue sucked but have you seen the bit with han and leah the ewok village its as bad or worse.plus my three kids fave is aotc out of all of them

Posted by kenny (127.0.0.1) on August 09, 2008 at 08:28 AM BST #

Saw it at a media screening at Vue Leister Square the other morning, was actually rather good, I`ve not been a fan of the prequels but for what it was a cartoon for kids and being Clone Wars Based, it was definatly a lot more fun to watch than any of the Prequels put together I recomend it.

Posted by Sacha (127.0.0.1) on August 11, 2008 at 02:58 PM BST #

"Millions of People went to see the 'new' star wars..millions left non-plused, I've met people who didn't bother with Ep 3 as the other 2 were so lame"

And millions more love them which kind of explains why these films were so successful and some the highest grossing in cinema history, not to mention breaking records for DVD sales. Sorry but the facts say otherwise.

" I have yet to meet someone who regards the 1-3 films and anywhere near as cool as 4-6."

You have now...................me!!!!!!

Star Wars Rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Cybos (127.0.0.1) on August 11, 2008 at 03:14 PM BST #

I find it amazing how much blah blah blah can be expressed before anyone has actually seen the film.

Or have I misunderstood the purpose of this REVIEW/comments page?

Posted by James (127.0.0.1) on August 13, 2008 at 01:11 AM BST #

SW films in general have wonderful special FX and sci-fi concepts, but pompous and obvious dialog and characters, which became worse in episodes 1,2,3. I guess you could say the series forms a flawed masterpiece: part brilliance, part incompetence. I'm always surprised at big-budget movies that neglect dialog. For me, the real Star Wars is in games like KotOR, Jedi Academy and many more. They are much more engaging that the movies.
As for Clone Wars, I'm not at all interested in seeing it. I imagine it will be visually appealing, but in many other respects shallow and superficial, just like the previous movie releases.

Posted by Xerxes (127.0.0.1) on August 13, 2008 at 01:30 AM BST #

I really regret watching this..what a waste!

It's only saving graces was some of the world looks. A real disappointment..

Posted by Zak (127.0.0.1) on August 16, 2008 at 09:55 PM BST #

I went to see this film on Saturday. As a fan of the original Clone wars TV series by Genndy Tartakowski (Creator of Samurai Jack) I was expecting a fun and action packed Star Wars film. On this account it delivered. I would agree that it is very much like a SW fan film with a bigger finance budget. This is a good thing in my book. It gives a good account of the SW universe and deserves some credit. Looking forward to the TV series.

Posted by DH (127.0.0.1) on August 17, 2008 at 11:22 PM BST
Website: http://www.credit-finance-guide.co.uk #

Ok, as the review above says, how can people actually review this if they have not seen it.....I have...saw it today. I am a SW fan through and through....I will admit the prequels do have their flaws, but so do the originals...if you watch New Hope now, nothing happens for about 40 minutes after the opening scene! A lot of bad mouthing is down to nostalgia....your mind remembers things to be better then they actually are...

Anyway, back to this film! I must admit, the 98 minutes flew past.....a real action fest! Something obviously that can only be done using this type of CGI. My kids did not move out of their seats and they normally spend a lot of the time going to the toilets in the cinema.
The plot worried me slighly though...how come Jabbas offspring is not mentioned before? As well as Ziro the Hutt, Captain Rex, Anakins Padawan etc? this annoys me greatly as a lot of effort is built into the games and novels to then try and tie up a lot of these continuity problems which seem to be constantly created by Lucas.

This leads on to the other worrying part....so many toys and Lego kits released again....all these new devices seem to appear just as kids have stopped playing with the last ones. This time however I think the toy sales will be a huge flop....my son is more interested in Transformers and Indiana Jones.

All in all I think the action is good, but why introduce so many new characters when so many already existed? I can't help thinking that Lucas would have been better exploring the time between ROTS and New Hope....using the Clone Wars seems to be a good excuse for creating more toys and Playstation games.

Posted by Jase (127.0.0.1) on August 19, 2008 at 01:29 AM BST #

I took my daughter to see this at the weekend. On leaving the smile on her face was something to behold until I seen my reflection in the doors leaving the cinema. This is what Stars Wars is all about and bode's well for the series. To quote my daughter 'Bring it on'

Posted by dk-highlander (127.0.0.1) on September 23, 2008 at 12:43 PM BST #

Post a Comment:

Name:
E-Mail:
URL:

Your Comment:

HTML Syntax: NOT allowed
SFX Movie Trailers

Calendar