SFX
SFX Merchandise
Newsletter

20091125 Wednesday November 25, 2009

BLOG Don't keep the magic a secret

Are you following the BBC's Merlin? Blogger John Cooper champions the current series of the young wizard:


Thoughts on the current season of Merlin so far

Now nearing the end of second series the current run of consistently solid stories has been pretty impressive stuff. While the first series was indeed a good start, it also seemed like a cunning marketing plan to blend the successful sub-genre of boy wizard into the new Saturday night spot carefully nurtured by Russell T Timelord. Season one was good, but wasn't exactly required viewing and some of the stories were a little pedestrian.

Series two has come on leaps in bounds in both character development and narrative as if producers Julian Murphy and Jonny Capps, bitten by the failure of ITV's Demons, have run off into a forest of criticism, sharpened their mission statement and come charging out again wielding scripts and a point to prove.

From creepy child Mordred snuffing out guards to a very original two-parter with a troll and some great guest stars in Colin Salmon, Charles Dance and Emilia Fox as Morgause, causing a violent confrontation between father and son in “Sins of the Father”, there's been plenty to chew on down in ye-olde Camlelot.

The core of the show has been nailed in the performances of the main cast: Anthony Head's Uther Pendragon is a wonderfully balanced performance of a king ruling with an iron fist and horribly one sided view of sorcery, yet managing to find enough shreds of compassion to make you care about him. While Richard Wilson as Gaius pulls out all the stops when he's tortured by a witchfinder, and when the witchfinder is the deliciously harsh looking Charles Dance, who seems like he brought his own costume from home, it's telly drama as rich and sweet as chocolate cheesecake.

Colin Morgan has become increasingly watchable as Merlin with a natural desire to use his powers, if only to make horses out of smoke (admit it - if you could, you would too), and more so when he's given open ended and ambiguous moral dilemmas to deal with. I'll be honest I've yet to warm to Bradley James as Arthur, who has been perhaps a little too smug and posh at times.

I'm not sure how accurate the characters or portents are to established Arthurian folklore, apart from the obvious conceit of "Merlin and Arthur – The Early Years". But unlike the recently departed Robin Hood, the style and tone of the show fit like a glove and have developed some real depth as evidenced by evolving dialogue between the two main guys, where the young men seem to be slowly relinquishing the master/servant relationship, in favour of a genuine friendship.

Lets just hope those all important ratings do well enough for a third season.


Are you enjoying Merlin? Hit us with your thoughts below. SFX's own reviews will appear in issue 191.

This blog is a personal article by comedian and writer John Cooper, who (by the way) is coming to perform at the SFX Weekender.


Advertisement
Trackback URL:
Comments:

I. Love. Merlin (especially Colin Morgan...). Having said that, I'm a little disappointed with how season 2 is progressing. I felt that after the leaps and bounds that the Merlin/Arthur friendship took on in season one that the lack of trust and back step they took in the first ep of season two was misplaced. I thought that we would have seen more from Morgana (especially with her powers) and Gwen who have had some episodes with no impact. I think that the first season had more interesting and lively story lines but that series two has benefited from a larger production budget (jousting!!). I'm hoping that it gets really hot and heavy with the action in the remainder of the season...bring it on guys!

Posted by Heather (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 09:30 AM GMT #

Loving season 2 of Merlin (and especially the episode Emilia Fox was in)Its a shame Gwen and Morgana have been sidelined somewhat, but I get the feeling both will come back to the fore eventually.

Can't agree with the notion that the author hasn't waremed to Bradley James' Arthur. For me the interplay between Merlin and Arthur is the best thing about the show, and I think James does a great job of playing Arthur bot as an arrogant prince and a genuinely noble man at the same time.

The scene between Arthur and Merlin about the dress in the last episode was just brilliant!

Posted by Paul Starkey (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 10:50 AM GMT
Website: http://www.cityofcaves.me #

Love the amount of Arthurian legend stuff that's being set up this season - hopefully the series will last long enough for it all to come to fruition. There certainly seems plenty of story to last for years.

Agree with Paul that James does a good job making Arthur both arrogant and likeable. Only complaint is the lack of Morgana this year (although I guess the series is called 'Merlin').

Posted by Jon (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 11:50 AM GMT #

I think that "smug and posh" is exactly the way this version of Arthur should be. And I just love the inter-play between him and Merlin.
The troll episodes were particularly glorious.

Posted by Tom (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 05:10 PM GMT #

Although I'm enjoying this series of Merlin and the central performances I'm a little disapointed how much the girls have been pushed to the background. Gwen actually became a good character earlier on in series 2 giving Angel Coulby some good material but Morgana after she took over the latter half of last series (the series should have been entitled Morgana) has had nothing to do what so ever. She needs her own spin off and quick as this series has made her the damsel in distress with little mind of her own.

Posted by Aegis of Atreyu (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 09:22 PM GMT #

I'm absolutely loving this series of Merlin, which came as a bit of a surprise after the last one. They've sidestepped the regular format it took in series one and come up with some brilliant stories and characters. I can't wait for Morgause, and - please! - Freya to reappear. The acting's been wonderful, and Charles Dance as the Witchfinder had the best evil laugh I have ever heard. Chilling and not remotely hammy! Colin Morgan would steal the show if it wasn't already his. As for Morgana disappearing, reading the synopsis for the episode after the next one, I think she is about to come into her own and maybe lose some of her damsel in distress demeanor.

Posted by Nelly (127.0.0.1) on November 25, 2009 at 11:03 PM GMT #

Hello :) ,

`Merlin´ is the best series ever !!!
There are comedy, seriousness, action, adventures, love …
but also moments for reflections and very, very brilliant actors.

Above all, Colin Morgan :* surprises me more and more.
He is phenomenal not only in the last episode from `Merlin´.
He has all what a grandios actor involves.
His brilliant performance shows us all faces, reflective, sad, natural, comical,scared,serious...

The development of the story is very good.
One notices that the directors and writers, like Johnny Capps and Julian Jones have made themselves many thoughts.
Best wishes from Germany )
I´am watch BBC Merlin original in english,
Because original is better ever ^^.

Posted by Heike (127.0.0.1) on November 26, 2009 at 06:27 PM GMT #

If by "impressive" you mean "full of characters I no longer recognize and who change their characterization according to the needs of the current episode's plot", then yes, season 2 has been impressive.

GOSH, the writing is so lame, it's painful. Take the last episode: Freya was a flying beast, yet never flew away...to, you know...escape. I think Johnny and Julian actually believe that their backstory for the Lady of the Lake is more interesting than anything the legend has given us. NO, it's not. And it's certainly not clever.

I enjoyed the first season. But now I only watch for Bradley James's chest. And because he seems to be the only one in the know that huge parts of the audience don't want to see Arthur pine for a floozy (sorry, Gwen, but that's how you're written) who we know will break his heart. Because for some reason, the Guinevere/Lancelot part of the legend they had to keep in tact. Do remind me, wasn't the "real" Igraine as fertile as a rabbit?

Posted by Anty (127.0.0.1) on November 26, 2009 at 06:34 PM GMT
Website: http://community.livejournal.com/merlin_denial/ #

I think the show has great strengths (and some pretty obvious weaknesses) and I've really enjoyed both series. The plots have got stronger this year, but that has shown up the less good writing, particularly their resistance to moving the story on. The best thing about it is all six of the main cast, who are all excellent. Can't agree with you on Bradley James - he does a wonderful job of pulling all the ways Arthur is written depending on the needs of the plot into one believable person, and he and Colin Morgan are magic together.

Posted by Janet (127.0.0.1) on November 26, 2009 at 08:14 PM GMT #

It's me again :)

Janet has posted on November 26, 2009 at 08:14 PM GMT :
"he (Bradley James )and Colin Morgan are magic together."
This is my opinion too.

Like Paul Starkey and others here, I can't agree why the author hasn't waremed to Bradley James' Arthur.
He performs his character fantastic^^:), how the directors and writers want he to do.
It´s Bradley´s character in "Merlin"
If I´m think of the the episode "The Sins of the Father" ,Bradley was so grandios^^ and not only there ^^

Posted by Heike. (127.0.0.1) on November 27, 2009 at 02:51 AM GMT #

I hate it when poo gets stuck to my little furry tale.

Posted by Hoppy Flufftale (127.0.0.1) on November 29, 2009 at 07:32 PM GMT #

Post a Comment:

Name:
E-Mail:
URL:

Your Comment:

HTML Syntax: NOT allowed
SFX Movie Trailers

Calendar