SFX
SFX Merchandise
Newsletter

20090318 Wednesday March 18, 2009

BLOG Battlestar Expectations

Are you watching Battlestar Galactica? Here on SFX we consider it unmissable TV. But blogger Jamie Starbuck (coincidental name, no?) has a personal take on the run of episodes approaching the finale:


The End Of Battlestar Galactica

According to Luc Besson's The Fifth Element, anticipation implies intelligence. This would make the audience of new BSG a gestalt of Einsteins. Together, we could surely destroy the world.

And after the next episode we just may. It is the end, the final, the whatsit and the omega: after four seasons Battlestar Galactica comes to a stop. And what a damp squib it's going to be.

No-one can deny it'll probably be one of the best singular episodes of BSG, and possibly of anything, ever. BSG has given us some amazing television these past few years. The first season was one of the finest in celluloid history and there have been some brilliant moments in between: the rescue from New Caprica, Ellen Tigh's death and the revealing of the penultimate four to name but a few.

At some point however the law of diminishing returns came in to effect. I suspect it's something that will only be seen with a re-watch because as we were going through, carried along on a tide of excitement, I for one forgave every little hiccup and couldn't wait for the next week. Which fan didn't cry in anguish when it was announced there was going to be an end with four seasons? But, Ronald D Moore proclaimed, it will give us a chance to plan with exactitude what is to happen, for there shall be no filler. "Hurrah!" cried the fans.

But season four… let's face it season four has been less than ideal. Ignoring the fact that it was split into two (we could call it a positive and say it was like having five seasons) it's been slow in a way like never before. This is a show about robot wars for frak's sake! If you've got a slow episode chuck in a few whiz-bangs. But no. We've had seemingly endless episodes of pondering, of indecision, of Adama cracking up (again and again and again), of Sixes and Eights painting the ship (it appears Leoben doesn't paint) and of the final five squabbling between themselves. Or at least individual members and cliques thereof. Almost every episode has been filled with… well, filler.

Witness the entire expositional episode of The History Of The Final Five (AKA Anders reads stuff off the back of his eyeballs like he's an accountant). We'd been waiting nearly four years for this information! Was there something wrong with, ya know, actually having some of it acted in flashbacks spread throughout the season?

There have been good points, of course there have: Gaeta's pointless mutiny and the ever reliable Gaius Baltar are two but are they enough? There will have been 20 episodes this season by the time it's over and I could name specific events from only a few. There are rumours that a massively significant proportion of the shows seasonal budget has been spent on Saturdays two hour opus but no matter how good it is, I can't help but feel this season has sullied the reputation of the entire show. And that's a shame. Still, end of this week: whiz-bangs.


We admit, we're not sure what the pigeon scene was about in the previous episode, but we still love BSG and think it's shaping up for an explosive finale. This post above is a personal article by Jamie Starbuck, one of our new bloggers - read more about our volunteer contributors on this dedicated page.

So, are you a BSG fan? Are you quaking with anticipation about the series finale this Friday night (Tuesday in the UK on Sky)? Let us know what you think's been the best and worst of this season.


Advertisement
Trackback URL:
Comments:

Jamie, you're wrong. If you want whizz bang robot wars, go and watch.....well, Robot Wars. BSG has provided some of the finest, most exciting television of the past 10 years, and it's done that through blending character, action and sci-fi perfectly. To write off an entire season as a "damp squib" is a huge over-generalisation, only made to attract attention and reaction - which, to be fair, it's succeeded in doing from me. Well done. It's also plain wrong - this is the season that gave us the Mutiny, the devastation of Earth, the revelations of the Final Cylon and the history of the Final Five, the deaths of Dualla and Cally, the destruction of the Hub, the apparent ressurection of Starbuck and the fascinating rise and history of Cavil. It's a rich tapestry of stories, and it's actually going somewhere - yes, it requires investment, intelligence and patience from the viewer, but if that's not what you're after, there's always Flash Gordon.

I'm not sure I understand the point of the new bloggers, other than to try and be "contoversial" - I read the blog entry on Dollhouse as well, and had similar feelings. It reminds me of the kid at school who stopped liking his favorite band as soon as they became popular.

Posted by Adam (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 11:30 AM GMT #

"I'm not sure I understand the point of the new bloggers, other than to try and be "contoversial" - I read the blog entry on Dollhouse as well, and had similar feelings" - Adam

There isn't really anything controversial about saying that BSG hasn't lived up to its early promise or Dollhouse is a bit of a letdown. Both of these viewpoints seem to be the general consensus amoung viewers. I think the point with BSG is that the writers really let the mythology get away from them, and I think Jamie's point about how rubbish it was to have Anders just explain everything was fair.

Posted by -Eyes-only- (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 12:03 PM GMT #

Adam

The point of the new bloggers is to stir debate and get people contributing and discussing stuff more. There's a good variety of them with different opinions. It's not controversial to suggest that early episodes of Dollhouse have been poo, although the last episode was ace and there are a lot of BSG fans worried about the damp squibiness of the finale. Not being a BSG fan I don't really care, but I do think that they and Jamie should wait until it airs before commenting on whether it is going to be ace or not.

Posted by darrenmdr (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 12:11 PM GMT #

I don't just agree with this but I would expand it through the whole re-imagined series.

I don't mind being depressed, or watching hopeless battles but from day one the Cylons were so far ahead the fleet never stood a chance.
Worse than that the whole attitude of the galactica Crew annoys me. They frak, fight and prat about with each other when they should be banding together to survive.
An argument from the infinitely better original was humanity had to prove they were a race worth saving. In this one they haven't and I couldn't care less if they all die.

Posted by Arthur ElThurian (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 12:31 PM GMT #

Sorry, controversial is the wrong word - there's certainly no shortage of BSG-and-Dollhouse-critics. But it annoys me how quick some people are to discredit good sci-fi - especially given the sheer quantity of genuine rubbish that's out there.

I think BSG has balanced the mythology well - the show has evolved over the seasons, and the mythology has built up around that, but they've taken care and attention to ensure that it's coherant. Also, I don't need to SEE everything filtered through a fiery haze of burning starship in order to enjoy it - I was on the edge of my seat for the whole episode where Anders explains the Final Five's origin, the revelations themselves were enough. I agree the season has had some flaws (Adama's painting tantrum anyone?), but overall, it's expanded the story, provided some hugely entertaining TV, and, unless the final epsiode is a complete trainwreck, completed the BSG journey emotionally, coherantly and entertainingly. To write the whole thing off as a damp squib is just lazy.

Similarly with Dollhouse (off topic, I know) - two episodes in, self-proclaimed Whedon-ites were writing it off. It's still early days, and it's still establishing itself, but from what I've seen, it's entertaining, and has a huge amount of potential. TV shows need a chance to grow, evolve and expand their universes in order to become interesting. If it winds up getting cancelled, these same Whedon-ites will have no-one to blame but themselves.

Posted by Adam (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 01:05 PM GMT #

I still really fraking enjoy BSG but I do miss Apollo in his Viper, and I'm a bit disappointed with how they chose to develop Gaius Baltar's character (I really enjoyed watching him and six go at it like bunnies in Spring time), but with all that said I still think the finale will be fantastic. And Boomer is still hot. And I do love Romo Lampkin's mad as a hatter character. So overall, I'm quite pleased with how the show has turned out. And as a side note, if you've ever seen my husband Kyle, he TOTALLY looks like Galen. I can't believe I'm married to a frakin' skin job. I mean, love you hunny bunny! ...:)

I enjoyed reading your blog Jamie! Cheers x

Posted by Kell Harker (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 01:24 PM GMT #

Kell - OMG. You're so right about your hubby...

Adam - Whedonites make up a (gallingly) very small percentage of the total audience. To lay the blame at their feet for the failure of Dollhouse would be a little unfair. No, it's Mr Whedon, all the way...

Still Adam - I'd never discredit good sci-fi of any ilk. But good is in the eye of the beholder...

Posted by Jamie Starbuck (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 01:53 PM GMT #

What the frak are you talking about? I'm no fraking Skin Job.... NOW Does anyone hear that fraking music?

While the show is still really good, it's not as great as it was the first two season. I agree with my wife with being disappointed in how the story arc of Baltar is playing out. He was once the best character on the show and now he is almost written as an extra (with the last few episodes as exceptions) We have still not watched episode 19 yet but I am really looking forward to the 2 hour series finally.

Posted by Kyle Harker (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 02:20 PM GMT #

Jamie - of course everyone's entitled to their opinion - it all comes back to the age old question - What's art, and what's just a pickled sheep in a jar?

But, can you honestly say that this season of BSG is bad? We've seen Flash Gordon, we've seen Demons, we've seen Charmed - those are bad - BSG is light years ahead of them. Yes, the show's evolved, and Season 4 is more character driven than Season 1, which was a lot more action driven, which may not be to everyone's taste, but it doesn't make for a bad season.

As a fledgeling show, Dollhouse deserves our support even more - we know that the best shows need room to breathe, establish themselves and evolve - like Buffy - but some don't get that opportunity - like Firefly. You're talking about the "failure of Dollhouse" - it's only aired 5 episodes! Give it a chance, make a judgement at the end of the season, as to whether you want it back or not - but this early on, it needs support, and it needs positive word of mouth. It could never live up to our sky high expectations in just a handful of episodes, but the potential is huge.

Posted by Adam (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 02:38 PM GMT #

'According to Luc Besson's The Fifth Element, anticipation implies intelligence.' Hmmmm... and we know what an intelligent film the Fifth Element was...

My dog drools when I go near her bowl as she anticipates food, does that mean she's knocking on the door to Mensa?


I'm baffled as to how you think Season 4 has been 'filled with filler', given the rate that it has rattled through the story. I think if there is any criticism that can be levelled, it's that the last 10 episodes have felt too rushed at times! Of course this is because a decision has been made to finish the show and there was a lot of information that they needed to get across. This is also why Anders pretty much gave us the history of the Cylons, as there simply wasn't enough time to film that many flashbacks.

BSG has been the most consistantly awesome show on TV and Season 4 has been a fitting, thrilling, shocking climax to it.

That said, Dollhouse IS rubbish... and I'm a Whedonite.

Posted by Chrismk (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 04:35 PM GMT #

I never thought I'd see the day, but I agree 100% with Jamie.

The show hasn't been "consistently awesome" since the New Caprica episodes. The rest of S3 was dull in comparison, and I really hoped that the announcement that S4 would be the last would sharpen things up. Sadly, it hasn't. Instead it's limped along with largely dull story-lines and only the odd glimpse of how good the show could be. It hasn't been bad, just nowhere near it's best which is a real shame.

I'll watch to see how it all ends, but I won't be buying it on DVD to watch again. Farewell BSG, it was a nice attempt but you just fell way too short to be considered the classic it looked like you were destined to be.

Posted by Wolf 359 (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 06:18 PM GMT #

Have to say that while I have enjoyed most of the blogs with their difference in opinion and style all Jamie seems to do is consistently moan about whichever show has annoyed him that week. There have been some positive and interesting blogs which have made me consider things that I hadn't thought about before and some fun ones that have made me laugh but every time I read one of Jamie's all he does is moan. If I want to read Jamie moan about something that he doesn't like on TV I can go to the forum where he does so regularly. I want to read something that is more than an extended forum rant please.

Posted by Dave Probert (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 06:48 PM GMT #

If you've got satellite (and a time machine) you could watch about 20,000 hours of TV in any one week.

I'd sooner watch a "dull" episode of BSG than at least 19,998 of those other hours. Enjoy it while you can, people.

Posted by Kevin M, Wilmington (127.0.0.1) on March 18, 2009 at 11:24 PM GMT #

Post a Comment:

Name:
E-Mail:
URL:

Your Comment:

HTML Syntax: NOT allowed
SFX Movie Trailers

Calendar